Cookie Flavors, Collections & Pricing

Find the Right Cookie Option for Your Celebration

Choose plain lemon cookies or one of our four custom-decorated cookie collections. Decorated cookies are currently available in Classic Vanilla or Lemon Vanilla.

Not Sure Which Collection Fits Your Idea?

You do not have to choose perfectly. Select the collection that appears closest to your vision and upload your inspiration pictures with your inquiry. Robin will review the number of designs, colors, lettering, shapes, and details before confirming the appropriate collection and final quote.

Lemon Cookie Options

Plain or Decorated Lemon Cookies

Our bright, buttery lemon cookie can be enjoyed plain or used as the base for a custom-decorated cookie set.

Plain pricing applies only to undecorated lemon cookies. Decorated lemon cookies are paired with vanilla icing and priced according to the custom collection that matches the requested design.
$3 Per Plain Cookie
$18 Plain Half Dozen
$36 Plain One Dozen
Lemon Cookie + Vanilla Icing Available for custom-decorated orders. Pricing begins with the decorated collection that matches the complexity of your design. Available Now
Lemon Cookie + Lemon Icing This pairing is still being tested for flavor, consistency, and decorating quality. Coming Soon
Simple & Minimal Detailed & Elaborate
Simple & Classic

Simply Sweet Collection

Best for: Simple favors, thank-you cookies, small gatherings, and clean, minimal designs.

$4 starting price
per cookie

Starting at $48 per dozen

This Collection Typically Includes

  • 1–2 simple cookie designs
  • Up to 3 coordinating icing colors
  • Basic shapes and minimal piping
  • Short names, initials, numbers, or simple messages
  • Small dots, stars, borders, or basic decorative details
  • No detailed characters, logos, florals, or layered artwork
Examples That Usually Fit
  • Heart cookies with a name or initial
  • Simple number cookies with dots or small stars
  • Thank-you cookies using one shape and two colors
Most Popular

Sweet Celebrations Collection

Best for: Birthdays, baby showers, graduations, and themed celebrations that need a few coordinating designs and personalized details.

$5 starting price
per cookie

Starting at $60 per dozen

This Collection Typically Includes

  • Up to 3–4 coordinating designs
  • Up to 5 icing colors
  • Names, ages, and short celebration messages
  • Moderate piping and simple themed details
  • Basic textures or light layered icing
  • Simple designs repeated throughout the set
Examples That Usually Fit
  • Baby shower set with a onesie, bottle, and “Welcome Baby” cookie
  • Birthday set with a cake, balloons, age, and name cookie
  • Graduation set with caps, diplomas, year, and school colors
Detailed & Personalized

Signature Sweets Collection

Best for: Detailed themed sets with several custom elements, textures, personalized wording, or more advanced decorating techniques.

$5.50 starting price
per cookie

Starting at $66 per dozen

This Collection Typically Includes

  • Up to 5–6 coordinating designs
  • Up to 7 icing colors
  • Detailed hand-lettering and personalized wording
  • Multiple textures and layered icing
  • Florals, bows, themed objects, or simplified characters
  • One or two highly detailed focal cookies
Examples That Usually Fit
  • Sports set with jerseys, balls, scoreboard, name, and age
  • Woodland shower set with animals, greenery, and layered wording
  • Spa birthday set with robes, candles, slippers, and face masks
Most Elaborate

Sweet Luxury Collection

Best for: Elaborate statement sets where many cookies have different designs, intricate artwork, or highly customized details.

$6 starting price
per cookie

Starting at $72 per dozen

This Collection Typically Includes

  • Up to 10 or more unique designs
  • Intricate hand-lettering and personalized messages
  • Detailed logos, characters, or brand-inspired artwork
  • Dimensional bows, tags, florals, and textures
  • Complex shapes and extensive layered icing
  • The greatest amount of planning and decorating time
Examples That Usually Fit
  • A children’s character-themed birthday set includes several different character faces, a custom design, the child’s name, age, and detailed lettering throughout the set.
  • Princess set with a castle, carriage, gown, crowns, and florals
  • Fashion birthday set with handbags, heels, perfume, bows, and gift boxes

Real-Life Collection Examples

Which Example Sounds Most Like Your Order?

These examples are general guides. The same party theme may fall into different collections depending on the number of designs and the amount of detail requested.

1

Simply Sweet

A customer orders twelve heart cookies in two colors. Each cookie includes a short name, initial, or simple birthday message.

Why it fits: one shape, minimal details, and one repeated design.
2

Sweet Celebrations

A baby shower set includes three simple designs: a baby onesie, bottle, and a coordinating “Welcome Baby” cookie in four colors.

Why it fits: three basic designs with moderate personalization.
3

Signature Sweets

A sports birthday set includes jerseys, balls, a scoreboard, team colors, the child’s name and age, and layered icing details.

Why it fits: several coordinated designs, lettering, and added texture.
4

Sweet Luxury

A colorful children’s character-themed birthday set featuring several different character faces, a custom street sign, the child’s name and age, detailed lettering, layered icing, and many unique designs.

Why it fits: many unique designs, character artwork, and intricate details.

What Counts as a Different Design?

The collection is not determined only by the party theme. It is also based on how many separate cookie designs must be planned, cut, piped, lettered, and decorated.

🍪 Shape A onesie, bottle, name cookie, cake, balloon, and number are each considered separate designs.
🎨 Decorating Technique Layered icing, detailed piping, florals, textures, characters, and dimensional elements increase complexity.
✍🏽 Personalization Multiple names, long messages, detailed lettering, logos, and individually personalized cookies require additional time.

How Your Final Quote Is Determined

📸 Share Your Inspiration Upload pictures and describe the occasion, wording, colors, and cookie designs you would like.
🎨 Robin Reviews the Details The number of designs, shapes, colors, lettering, textures, and advanced details are carefully reviewed.
💌 Receive Your Quote Robin confirms the appropriate collection and sends a personalized quote for the complete order.
Important Cookie Pricing Information
  • Collection prices are starting prices and may increase based on the final requested design.
  • A children’s character-themed set does not automatically fall into one collection. Simple, repeated designs may fit a lower collection, while a set featuring several detailed character faces, custom signs, layered icing, and many unique designs may require the Sweet Luxury Collection.
  • Complex lettering, logos, character artwork, metallic details, unusual shapes, dimensional decorations, and extensive personalization may affect the quote.
  • Plain lemon cookies are $3 each, $18 per half dozen, or $36 per dozen.
  • Decorated lemon cookies are paired with vanilla icing and priced according to the appropriate custom collection.
  • Lemon icing is currently in development and is not yet available for ordering.
  • Every cookie is individually heat sealed to preserve freshness and quality.
  • Decorative ribbon or bows may be added for an additional fee.
  • The required 50% non-refundable deposit secures the event date. An order is not confirmed until the deposit has been received.
Submit Your Cookie Inquiry

Upload inspiration pictures for the most accurate collection match

⏰

Rush Orders

Need cookies on short notice? We understand that last-minute celebrations happen!
  • Orders needed within 7 days are subject to a 20–30% rush fee, depending on the complexity of the design.
  • Rush orders are not guaranteed and are accepted based on availability.
  • We recommend placing your order as early as possible to ensure availability.
For last-minute inquiries, please contact us directly before submitting your order.
🎀

Optional Add-Ons

  • Ribbon & Gift Tag — +$1 per cookie
  • Printed Photo Cookies — Starting at $6 each
  • Printed Logo Cookies — Starting at $4 each
Looking for something custom? Let us know in your inquiry, and we'll do our best to bring your vision to life.

Keeping Your Cookies Fresh

Cookie Care

Follow these instructions to protect the flavor, freshness, and decorated details of your cookies after pickup or delivery.

Store, Freeze & Enjoy

Every cookie is individually heat sealed. Keep the package closed until you are ready to serve or enjoy the cookie.

Do Not Refrigerate

Please do not place decorated cookies in the refrigerator. Refrigeration and moisture may affect the texture, colors, and decorated icing.

Store at Room Temperature

Keep cookies inside their original heat-sealed bags and store them at room temperature in a cool, dry area away from direct sunlight, heat, and humidity.

Freshness

When kept inside their unopened heat-sealed bags at room temperature, cookies may remain fresh for up to two weeks.

Freezing Your Cookies

Keep each cookie inside its heat-sealed bag. Place the sealed cookies inside an airtight, freezer-safe container before freezing. Cookies may be frozen for up to three months.

Thawing Frozen Cookies

Remove the closed container from the freezer at least 12 hours before serving. Allow the cookies to return completely to room temperature before opening the container or any heat-sealed bags.

Traveling with Cookies

Keep the cookie box flat and secure during transportation. Do not place heavy items on top of the box or leave cookies inside a hot vehicle.

Important thawing reminder: Opening the container while the cookies are still cold may allow condensation to form on the decorated surfaces. Keep the container closed until everything has reached room temperature.
Enjoy your cookies! ♡
✦ ✧ ✦ ✧

Ready to Create Something Sweet?

Every order is thoughtfully customized with your vision in mind. We would love to help bring something beautiful and memorable to your next celebration.

Start Your Order

Custom Cookies • Personalized Gifts • Metro Detroit